← Back to Blog

Feast Only on Feast Days: Why Your Week Shouldn't Eat Like a Holiday

In Sanctify Your Day, I ask a question that I first heard from Fr. Mike Schmitz that still makes me squirm a little: "if Catholicism were illegal and I were to record your typical day and show it to the authorities, would they have enough objective proof to convict you?"

Now take that question into your kitchen. If someone opened your fridge on a random Tuesday, could they tell Lent from Christmas? A Friday from a Sunday?

For most of us (me included, at times), the honest answer is no. Every day looks the same, and every day looks like a party.

Your Pantry Shouldn't Look Like a Tailgate

Chips, soda, candy, ice cream, a drink to "unwind." None of these things are evil. You'd expect to see them at a tailgate or a Christmas party. The problem is that a lot of us keep our homes stocked with them all the time, for no better reason than that it's Tuesday.

And here's what nobody tells you: when every day is a feast, no day is. As I put it in the book, "If every day you eat and drink as if it's a feast day, what's the point of eating that way on an actual feast day?"

You lose twice. Your health takes a hit, and the real celebrations lose their joy. Christmas cookies don't hit the same when you've had cookies every night since Halloween.

(Full disclosure: my weakness is cheesecake. Well, really any baked goods. So trust me, I get it.)

The Church Already Gave You a Calendar

The good news? You don't need a new diet. The Church has been handing us a rhythm for two thousand years.

The life of a Catholic is seasonal. Every Sunday is a little Easter, and canon law protects "the joy proper to the Lord's day" (Can. 1247). Each year unfolds around the greatest feast of all: "Beginning with the Easter Triduum as its source of light, the new age of the Resurrection fills the whole liturgical year with its brilliance" (CCC 1168). Easter is the "Feast of feasts" (CCC 1169).

Feasting is biblical. When the people of Israel heard the law read aloud and began to weep, they were told:

"Go your way, eat the fat and drink sweet wine and send portions to him for whom nothing is prepared; for this day is holy to our Lord; and do not be grieved, for the joy of the Lord is your strength" (Neh. 8:10).

But Scripture is just as clear that everything has its season: "a time to weep, and a time to laugh; a time to mourn, and a time to dance" (Eccles. 3:4). Lent shouldn't look like Christmas. Easter shouldn't feel like Ordinary Time. And a random Wednesday shouldn't look like a solemnity.

Fridays Still Count (All Year)

When He was asked why His disciples didn't fast, Jesus answered, "Can the wedding guests mourn as long as the bridegroom is with them? The days will come, when the bridegroom is taken away from them, and then they will fast" (Matt. 9:15).

Those days are here, and the Church marks them weekly. Think Friday penance ended with Vatican II? Not quite. Canon law says the penitential days of the universal Church "are every Friday of the whole year and the season of Lent" (Can. 1250), and that abstinence from meat, "or from some other food as determined by the Episcopal Conference, is to be observed on all Fridays, unless a solemnity should fall on a Friday" (Can. 1251).

Here in the US, our bishops allow us to swap meat abstinence outside of Lent for another act of penance. But that's a substitution, not a cancellation. If you aren't abstaining from meat, you should still be abstaining from something.

Meanwhile, the culture yells "TGIF" and makes Friday the night to let loose with takeout and drinks. The day set aside to remember Christ's sacrifice has become the biggest indulgence night of the week.

That's dis-ordered. Literally. It's out of order.

Feast Like You Mean It

Now, don't hear what I'm not saying. This isn't a post about never enjoying food. We are not Stoics, and we're definitely not called to be joyless.

In The God of Endurance, Dan Burke and I share a story about St. Francis of Assisi. When his brothers asked whether they should abstain from meat on Fridays during Christmas, he gave them leave to eat meat. Why? As we put it in the book, "It is actually disordered to fast on days on which the Lord calls us to celebrate."

Feasting is part of our faith. So is fasting. The virtue that holds them together is temperance, which the Catechism describes as "the moral virtue that moderates the attraction of pleasures and provides balance in the use of created goods" (CCC 1809). Temperance doesn't mean misery. As I like to say, "The goal of all virtue, but temperance especially, is your freedom."

Your Weekly Feast-and-Fast Rhythm

So what does this look like in an actual week? Here's a simple rhythm to start with:

  • Monday through Thursday: ordinary days. Fuel for your mission. Build your meals around protein, fiber-rich fruits and vegetables, and plenty of water. Keep the treats out of the house.
  • Friday: a penitential day. No meat OR pick one comfort to fast from, like dessert, snacking between meals, or the Friday night drink.
  • Saturday: prep day. Shop, cook ahead, and plan Sunday's meal.
  • Sunday: feast. Make dessert, open the wine, and linger at the table. This is the day for it.
  • Solemnities: feast too. Grab a Catholic calendar and mark the big ones (Christmas, Easter, the Assumption, All Saints, your parish's patron) so you're celebrating the Church's holy days, not just the Super Bowl.

Then ask yourself honestly: Do my Fridays include some form of fasting? Do I save my biggest indulgences for game days instead of holy days?

One word of caution. When my wife (then girlfriend) and I tried Nineveh 90 in college, I did bread-and-water fasts twice a week and got short with everyone around me. My confessor put it bluntly: "Chase, you know fasting isn't supposed to make you a worse person, right?" He told me to scale back to Fridays only, and it worked. Start small. Penance should make you more loving, not more irritable. If food has become a source of anxiety or compulsion, talk with your doctor or a counselor before adding any fasting.

I promise you, if you save feasting for feast days and live in moderation the rest of the time, most of your food problems might just take care of themselves. "So, whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God" (1 Cor. 10:31).

Want Help Building Your Rhythm?

If you want a coach to help you build a way of eating that fits your vocation and the Church's calendar, that's exactly what we do at Hypuro Fit.

Book your free discovery call today and let's build a plan that fits your life.

And for the full framework this habit comes from, pick up my book Sanctify Your Day.

Laudem Gloriae,
Chase Crouse
Founder, Hypuro Fit

Free Weekly Newsletter

Faith. Fitness. Every Week.

Training, nutrition, and faith-driven insights delivered every week.
    🏋️ Get a Coach 📱 Try the App